Dog Control and Welfare
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee
Wednesday, 6 February 2013
Parliamentary committees
House of Commons
Tuesday, 16 April 2013
Parliamentary committees
House of Commons
A very warm good afternoon to you, Mr Turner; I welcome you to your place. It is a pleasure to se...
I know that all the families affected will welcome this debate. Does the hon. Lady share my conce...
Show all contributions (74)
I think that the Committee would like to record our disappointment that it took so long to produc...
Could the Government make good that slight on the Committee by introducing draft guidance—they ha...
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman, and I am sure that the Minister will have heard his remarks;...
I am grateful to my hon. Friend the Chair of the Select Committee for her excellent speech, and I...
I welcome my hon. Friend’s intervention. It is important that we get the measure right. The paral...
I thank the Chair of the Select Committee for giving way and compliment her on her report. She ma...
My hon. Friend reinforces the Select Committee’s point that the microchip is a tool but not the w...
As the hon. Lady rightly highlights, the CWU makes that point strongly, because of the number of ...
The Committee and I welcome what the hon. Lady says. When I visited the Blue Cross home in my own...
Once again, I commend the Chair of the Select Committee on her contribution. Does she agree that ...
I welcome the intervention by the hon. Gentleman; I am tempted to call him my hon. Friend. On a n...
The hon. Lady has been generous in allowing me to make many interventions. On the point about bre...
Indeed. That was one of our conclusions. One hesitates to use the word “bitch”, but in this debat...
As with driving offences, we must differentiate between those people who are deliberately setting...
Indeed. I am grateful to the hon. Lady for those comments. I do not know if that was what the sha...
I start by saying how much I welcome the two reports on this issue from the Environment, Food and...
Does my hon. Friend share my concern that the Government’s proposals in the Anti-social Behaviour...
I agree, and because the proposals are subsumed in antisocial behaviour legislation, not enough p...
My hon. Friend makes a good point about prioritising the matter among the wide range of measures ...
I agree. My hon. Friend raises some important points.
The dog control notice could say, “Ke...
I am a little concerned that in the debate about dog control notices, which, for the reasons the ...
Absolutely. I agree that people may be concerned that it is cruel to keep a dog muzzled. However,...
May I correct the record? I previously said that 20,000 people had signed the petition, but the f...
I join my hon. Friend in congratulating the people involved. Dogs are similar to children, and ea...
Order. There are about 15 minutes per person remaining.
2.15 pm
It is a great pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I will try to ensure that my ...
Local authorities spend about £57 million a year on kennelling costs, when dogs are thought to be...
The Blue Cross hospital here in London might have dogs of a breed that is considered vicious, yet...
I am grateful for the opportunity to speak, Mr Turner, and I am sorry that I was a few minutes la...
I am grateful that I have caught your eye, Mr Turner. Dogs’ hackles are up and their hair is on e...
I am delighted that we are able to debate this important issue in response to the seventh report ...
Does the hon. Gentleman agree that this is precisely the type of issue that needs to be widely co...
Very much so. The hon. Gentleman made that point well in terms of the organisational structure th...
To put the hon. Gentleman’s mind at rest, I can tell him that when we looked at the issue in our ...
I welcome that intervention, and I welcome the fact that the Committee’s thinking has evolved bas...
indicated assent.
The Minister is nodding, so I know he is going to say a lot of good things in his response.
indicated dissent.
I see the Minister shaking his head and I know that he will come back on that issue. I am glad to...
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for giving way twice, but I believe that we have time to deba...
I hope that the hon. Gentleman will be on the Committee—I will not be—because I think that is an ...
We have had an excellent debate. I commend the hon. Member for
...Will the Minister confirm that Lord de Mauley—great chap that he is—chairs some cross-Whitehall g...
He has certainly been working closely with others, including the devolved Administrations—but par...
I should declare that I am a Scottish advocate, albeit a non-practising one. I am aware of the cr...
That is where we need detailed and careful examination of the proposals. I accept the point that ...
I am tempted to use, or subvert, an old adage, and say that I have been patronised in better plac...
I very much understand that, having sat in more Bill Committees over the years than I care to enu...
I may be pre-empting the Minister’s comments, but another concern is about prioritising and resou...
That is difficult for me to answer, because it will be in the hands of local authorities in combi...
I thank the Minister for his explanation. To give him some comfort, when I was in his position an...
Having now conceded the fact that when he was in my position in government he received exactly th...
Will you do it?
I will certainly discuss with my noble Friend whether the matter commends itself to him, and he w...
It would be a great test for your civil servants.
It might be a good examination question—we sometimes refer such matters to the Law Commission for...
I am sorry; I am behind the times. It was Tewkesbury. I say to my hon. Friend the Member for The ...
I thank the Minister for the detailed responses that he has given. I do not want to pre-empt subs...
That pre-empts not only the legislation but the secondary legislation that we are introducing, al...
My hon. Friend has been speaking for a long time and has given us a huge amount of detailed infor...
I most certainly will. I have the unprecedented benefit of having rather longer than usual to rep...
The point I was making is that there would be clarity if the number was simply two litters. Local...
I do not think that it would be a defence to say that there were fewer than five litters. It woul...
I hear what the Minister says, but it seems that the support council was set up with undue haste ...
I cannot answer that because the council is not a body of Government; it is independent of Govern...
Obviously, the hon. Member for Ogmore feels that I have not spoken for long enough, so I give way...
The Minister is being generous. I do not want to take time away from the hon. Member for Thirsk a...
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman, because I did miss that out. At the moment, there is no evid...
I welcome you to the Chair, Mr Brady. I thank the Liaison Committee for allowing us to debate the...
Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill 2013-14
Draft Dangerous Dogs (Amendment) Bill