Strengthening the Union
I beg to move,
That this House has considered strengthening the Union.
The Prime Mini...
Perhaps the Minister can explain, then, why the former Foreign Secretary described Northern Irela...
Show all contributions (232)
The hon. Gentleman did the job himself in the final few words of his intervention. I will look fo...
The Minister talks about benefiting all, but as she is aware, the UK is the most unequal state in...
The hon. Gentleman highlights an important point that we will have the opportunity to consider wh...
I speak as a proud Unionist, and I am very much in favour of the Union. The Minister must underst...
I am sure that we will come on to all those points during the debate. However, the hon. Gentleman...
I am sure that many Members from all over the United Kingdom will point to the inequalities and t...
That is precisely my point. When we see what we can do as a larger economy—when we see how we can...
Will the Minister give way?
I must make a few more moments of progress. We have a full debate ahead of us on the strengths of...
Will the Minister give way?
Yes, I will now.
I am very grateful to the Minister—and may I compliment her on her rather fine Sean Connery impre...
I do not think the hon. Gentleman can have been listening when I included, for example, car produ...
May I take this opportunity to congratulate the Minister on the ninth anniversary of her election...
Yes, that is exactly why the UK Government took those steps, and we are proud to have done so.
A freedom of information request has just shown today that the Ministry of Defence is not paying ...
I confess that I am not in possession of that information, and I am not in a position to give the...
Northern Ireland suffered from 40 years of terrorism at the hands of those who wished to overturn...
Yes, I think that is right. The right hon. Gentleman also reminds us of the importance of the pri...
I am sure the Minister recognises the contribution of the people in uniform in Northern Ireland. ...
I join the hon. Gentleman and everyone in the House in paying tribute to those who serve this cou...
On the new powers that will come to the Scottish Government in particular, it has never been more...
Mr Speaker—[Interruption.] I am sorry, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have clearly had yet more of that ...
The Minister has very conveniently skipped over Brexit. Over the weekend we learned that a no dea...
It is not my Union but the entire country’s Union. It is something we should be proud of; it is s...
I am grateful to the Minister for giving way again. There can be no more important document on th...
I am not going to comment on individual documents here. The forum I chair, and the JMC structure ...
Today’s debate is on “Strengthening the Union”, so I am going to start by talking about that conc...
The hon. Lady is speaking in glowing terms about our Union. Does she agree with the hon. Member f...
I am indeed a proud Unionist. I am also a very proud Scot. Having supported and competed for my c...
We hear a lot about SNP Members coming up with grievances. When the hon. Lady looks at the state ...
Of course I am absolutely appalled by the levels of poverty, but I also recognise that the Scotti...
My hon. Friend raises an interesting point. Millions of people in this country are the “working p...
My hon. Friend makes a good point. We are aware that many studies now show that many people using...
Does the hon. Lady not think this is slightly hypocritical, given that her colleagues in the Scot...
The hon. Gentleman has missed the point: the reason we stood up and supported the Scottish Govern...
I am glad the Labour party in Scotland has supported the Scottish Government on this issue, but c...
The hon. Gentleman has just illustrated his own point, which is that the basis of having devoluti...
You said that little bit.
I did. It was worth repeating. While these policies continue to have a cruel impact on the lives ...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
I wish to make some progress.
In recent weeks, we have been presented with the evidence of ...
The only political party that has had a cuts commission in Scotland during the past five years is...
The SNP’s document speaks for itself; not only that, but there are many commentators who have som...
My hon. Friend has made the pertinent point about the economic benefits of the Union to the Scott...
My hon. Friend raises a very good point. Economic analysis makes clear that the sums that the SNP...
Does the hon. Lady accept that the previous Labour Government put us in this financial mess in th...
That is certainly not the case. Having worked in the financial services sector at that time, I kn...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
I wish to make some progress.
It is Labour that will protect people in the workplace and cr...
This debate is about the Union and the constitution. I thought that Labour’s great innovation was...
The hon. Gentleman is right: that was in our manifesto and we will continue to work on it, becaus...
Order. This is a very well subscribed debate. I would prefer not to introduce a time limit, so if...
It is a real treat to be able to speak in the Chamber. As a Member who is not particularly fright...
On a point of order, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I hope it is a point of order.
We have just noticed that the Government Front-Bench spokesperson has scuttled out of the Chamber...
I have no idea whether the Minister has gone out temporarily, but there is another Minister on ha...
I quite agree, Madam Deputy Speaker. I was at that critical moment when I was about to discuss my...
To be fair, the Liberal Democrats were here earlier.
Now that is more like a bit of parliamentary humour, but the hon. Gentleman knows exactly who I m...
First, let me congratulate the Government on being so efficient at managing their legislative pro...
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for giving way during his comments about a massive disconnect...
If the hon. Gentleman bears with me, I am coming to that. I was in 1955 just there, but let me ju...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I am happy to give way, although I may be getting to the hon. Gentleman’s point in a minute.
The hon. Gentleman is a fine speaker in this Chamber, but I am not quite so sure that he can read...
I was coming to exactly that point, as it happens.
The Labour Wilson-Callaghan Government t...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I fear I need to crack on.
That’s fine—crack on.
I thank the hon. Gentleman. As he said, in 1979 we get the introduction of the Thatcher Governmen...
Let me remind the hon. Gentleman of the result of the September 2014 referendum, where, by a subs...
The result was 45:55. When the referendum campaign started, the split on the question had been ab...
Like my hon. Friend, I accept the referendum result, but is not the point that the minority have ...
It does indeed.
Democracy must allow people to exercise their right to revisit a decision i...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
No, because that really could not have been a controversial point.
Will the hon. Gentleman give way on that point?
Okay, on that point.
Would the hon. Gentleman then say that his leader in Scotland, Nicola Sturgeon, was wrong, ahead ...
No. I wish I had not given way now, because the hon. Gentleman was not wanting to comment on the ...
No, the hon. Gentleman has had his say.
The truth of the matter is that if one changes the ...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Edinburgh East (Tommy Sheppard). I do not agree wi...
It is a great pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Filton and Bradley Stoke (Jack Lopresti). I ...
I am happy to give way if the hon. Gentleman wants to clarify the comment, but we have it on the ...
To clarify the record, that is not what I said. I said that, in retrospect, had I been there at t...
The hon. Gentleman also said that the SNP in 1979 withheld consent. It did not withhold consent; ...
On a point of information—perhaps the hon. Gentleman was not here for the urgent question—there h...
I was not here for the urgent question, so I cannot clarify those figures, but I can say that in ...
The hon. Gentleman is repeating the oft-repeated myth about the border between Northern Ireland a...
That is an extraordinary comment. We will see what happens come 29 March 2019 or after the transi...
I have already given way to the hon. Gentleman, and “one opportunity” means “one opportunity”.
Will the hon. Gentleman way?
I cannot, because I need to wrap up. If the model in the growth commission report had been applie...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I cannot. Madam Deputy Speaker wants me to wrap up and I would not like to upset her.
I am happy to upset the hon. Gentleman, but I am not going to upset Madam Deputy Speaker.
I...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Edinburgh South (Ian Murray). I was, however, a li...
Will my hon. Friend take this opportunity to remind the House that all Conservative Members of Pa...
My hon. Friend makes a fair and reasonable point. While I voted remain, I am also a democrat. Jus...
The hon. Gentleman is the Vice-Chair of the Select Committee on Scottish Affairs. We have the Cha...
I agree with the hon. Lady. We work very well across that Committee. It is a good example of part...
The hon. Gentleman talks about fair pay for those in the armed forces. What about the 220 not get...
It is very clear that those in the armed forces who were going to be paying extra because of the ...
It seems a curious pleasure to be speaking in this debate this evening. Just when we thought the ...
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for giving way on this point, because it is important. He is ...
I will tell the hon. Gentleman what we will do: we will try to help him out with the issue about ...
On a point of order, Madam Deputy Speaker. The hon. Gentleman is criticising me for apparently ch...
I want to emphasise again that using points of order just to get interventions in the debate on t...
The people of Scotland are watching, and what they are observing is something that they do not pa...
Order. May I ask the hon. Gentleman to face the Chair?
Yes, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Let us look at where we are when it comes to Brexit. On the Brex...
Does the hon. Gentleman not accept that what he is describing is a power release from Brussels to...
I have never said anything about no powers coming back to the UK. The point is that the powers th...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I do not have time to take any more interventions.
I ask the Scottish Conservative MPs—I ma...
Order. I remind hon. Members that I said if they keep to less than 10 minutes, everyone will get ...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Perth and North Perthshire (Pete Wishart). I am tr...
I am sorry, but is the hon. Gentleman referring to the Scottish National party as a cult?
I mentioned that a cult is driving forward the break-up of the United Kingdom. If you are suggest...
Order. May I once again say that we do not use the word “you” when referring to Members across th...
I will do so, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Within my own home, there is not simply a matrimonial u...
Does the hon. Gentleman agree that the powers being devolved from here to the Governments in Holy...
I do agree with that; indeed, the hon. Gentleman has obviously seen the next line of my speech.
Is that not what No. 10 Downing Street is supposed to do?
That is a very interesting point. [Interruption.] Yes, it is, but while things are very good, the...
My hon. Friend is making an important point, just as the hon. Member for Glasgow South (Stewart M...
I believe the UK Government must do more in every policy area and, as my hon. Friend says, at eve...
It is a pleasure to be here on this of all Mondays, speaking up for my constituents in Coatbridge...
Can the hon. Gentleman tell me how many times he has voted against the Leader of Opposition, the ...
The point is that had the Tories done what they said they were going to do when they came down he...
The hon. Gentleman will be as aware as I am of the cuts across every policy budget area in Wales....
No, it is the fault of the two Governments we have got just now.
As Tony Graham, the Scotti...
How come that when that same measure was proposed by the SNP administration in Glasgow, Glasgow L...
It was not a council in Glasgow but a council in north Lanarkshire, and I voted for it.
We ...
It is a pleasure to speak in this debate.
We should speak about some of the positives of ou...
My hon. Friend is making a powerful speech about the positive benefits from this Union. Does he a...
I thank my hon. Friend, and I could not agree more. My office has been involved in helping out a ...
I am very grateful to the hon. Gentleman, my neighbour, for giving way—[Interruption.] He is from...
I thank my neighbour for his intervention. I am glad that we have so much common ground between u...
I am grateful to the Government for giving us this debate, because it has given me the opportunit...
I am wearing a suit.
He knows the suit I mean! If we are talking about clothing, the Union is more like a fur coat, na...
Will my hon. Friend enlighten the House as to why she thinks that account has deleted that tweet?...
I think that the account has perhaps deleted the tweet because it was getting so many retweets fr...
My hon. Friend is making an excellent speech. One of the people who have now said publicly that t...
Absolutely. He joins Murray Foote, one of the authors of “The Vow”, who has come round to the oth...
The hon. Lady is making a point about a very sensitive policy area, on which we have had a lot of...
I have campaigned solidly in favour of getting rid of the policy throughout the UK. All that the ...
I think it is important, before I get into the main context of my speech, to pick up some of the ...
Can I clarify the record, so that there is no misunderstanding? I think that I clarified the issu...
That is a very important clarification because I have checked the official record and I said, in ...
The hon. Lady has clarified that, and I have only 10 minutes in which to speak. I am grateful for...
Order. Is the hon. Gentleman going to take an intervention?
I think that the hon. Lady has clarified the position, and I have only a few minutes.
Perhaps the hon. Gentleman would like to take the intervention.
Having clarified the point, I should be grateful if the hon. Gentleman stopped repeating a statem...
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to move on, because I think that is an important point th...
May I take the hon. Gentleman back to his point about elections? What happened to the Conservativ...
Yes, and we have discussed that many times but, as a minority, we are governing in the United Kin...
I am always grateful to debate this issue with the hon. Gentleman. I have asked him to do this be...
The Ministry of Defence pays our hard-working and extremely brave servicemen and women the UK rat...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
No, I will not give way. How dare they say the £4 million annually that this UK Government are pa...
Does my hon. Friend sense, as I do, that the SNP’s objective is to get independence for Scotland ...
Absolutely. My hon. Friend makes a very serious point. The outcome of independence does not matte...
I am upset to be called after the hon. Member for Moray (Douglas Ross) because as a result I was ...
My hon. Friend is making a powerful speech about the fact that solidarity transcends borders and ...
I absolutely agree with my hon. Friend, and I wonder what the Windrush generation feel about thei...
I am delighted to rise to speak in this debate this evening. In fact, there is nowhere else I wou...
But Ruth Davidson promised that if Scotland voted no it would get to stay in the European Union. ...
I think the hon. Gentleman for that intervention, but of course she did no such thing. The people...
We hear a lot about this centralisation issue. Why was it that, when the Scottish Government brou...
I would have to look into that in more detail to find the exact reason why we abstained on that v...
I thank the hon. Members for Glasgow Central (Alison Thewliss) and for Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath ...
With the tie of the hon. Member for Edinburgh East (Tommy Sheppard)?
An orange tie. They would blend in well at that great celebration of Unionism in Northern Ireland...
I am going to do something that breaks with convention in this debate—I am going to say something...
And Lancashire!
And Lancashire, and quite right, too, Mr Deputy Speaker; one great Lancastrian speaks to another....
I do not dispute whether or not what the hon. Gentleman is saying is correct, but that is just a ...
I thank the hon. Gentleman for that interjection. You are right: it has nothing to do with that; ...
Order. This is not about private chats. You have to speak through the Chair. I know there is grea...
I apologise, Mr Deputy Speaker. I am speaking collegiately.
Looking at where we are going t...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Morecambe and Lunesdale (David Morris), who has pe...
I rise to defend and advance the cause of the Union: the most successful political and economic u...
May I just say to the hon. Gentleman that he is many things; a piece of scum is not one of them. ...
The hon. Gentleman is indeed honourable, because he has been the very first on social media to co...
What exactly have UK Departments rushed to devolve that they should not have devolved? [Interrupt...
Well, the British Transport Police, as my hon. Friend the Member for Ochil and South Perthshire (...
I am grateful for the support for that statement, if for nothing else I have said.
It is un...
It is a pleasure to contribute to what has so far been a somewhat enlightening debate.
The ...
It is interesting to follow the shadow Minister. He has been a Member of the House for a year and...
I will give way to the hon. Gentleman shortly, but I want to get into the crux of what I am going...
I thank my fellow Glasgow Member for giving way. I have to put to him that the fundamental ethos ...
I agree that the hon. Gentleman believes that to be the case. I am afraid I do not believe that t...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
No, I will not give way because I want to make some progress.
I want to quote a former Glas...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
How can I say no after quoting the hon. Gentleman’s constituency slogan?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for quoting what used to be my constituency phrase of “Look aboot ye”....
I am willing to accept that entirely, but that does not mean I have to stop arguing for it. Indee...
The hon. Gentleman is right to point out grievances that he has with this Government. Is it not t...
The hon. Gentleman is in a unique position, as is the hon. Member for Berwickshire, Roxburgh and ...
I again commend the hon. Gentleman for his spirited defence of democracy in this context, but why...
Perhaps I can help the hon. Gentleman. I know he believes what I am saying to be sincere. I do no...
First, I thank the Government for bringing this matter to the House for consideration. I do not u...
It is an honour to wind up the debate on behalf of the Opposition. It has been an interesting deb...
I will carry on, thank you.
No longer can Whitehall hold the purse strings, dictating from ...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
I am just about to finish.
We will transform the outdated political structures of this coun...
It is a pleasure to reply to this debate, in what is my last act as a Wales Minister before I mov...
If all this is so important, and if respecting devolution is so important, can the Minister expla...
The hon. Gentleman will know full well that this Government engaged massively with both the Welsh...
Given that the Minister is now a Defence Minister, I hope he will be able to help me. What was th...
The honest answer is: I do not know the answer to that question, but I will be honest about it an...