Deregulation Bill
Wednesday, 11 December 2013
Parliamentary committees
House of Lords
House of Commons
Thursday, 30 January 2014
Command papers
House of Lords
House of Commons
Show all related items (6)
Tuesday, 13 January 2015
Parliamentary proceedings
House of Commons
I inform the House that the amendment in the name of the hon. Member for Brighton, Pavilion (Caro...
I beg to move, That the Bill be now read a Second time.
I will begin by saying something th...
Show all contributions (188)
My right hon. Friend is starting to outline a delicious smorgasbord of deregulation. I am particu...
My hon. Friend raises an immensely important point. I was going to talk about it later, but let m...
It would be helpful if the right hon. Gentleman could tell us the number of regulations that he w...
That is a very tantalising thought, so I shall go back and see whether that is possible. I am sur...
The hon. Gentleman does not need to exert himself; I will give way to him again.
Of course,...
Order. Certainly the hon. Member for Bassetlaw does wave eccentrically. There is not necessarily ...
I certainly would not wish to offend the Minister; I merely want an answer. He said “many”; he sa...
I will send the hon. Gentleman a list. It will not be exhaustive, but I suspect it will contain h...
I will give way to both my hon. Friends, but then if the House will forgive me, I will make some ...
The hon. Member for Bassetlaw (John Mann) likes mountains, so I think that that might be the way ...
My hon. Friend is quite right. Leaving aside the badinage induced by Opposition Members, the seri...
I welcome the Bill and reassure my right hon. Friend that I would be surprised if history remembe...
I have good news for my hon. Friend: it is not a matter of considering it; we have done it. Every...
That is an excellent idea. I welcome the clause, but is it not the case that now that the EU regu...
In many instances there is a good case for not layering further domestic obligations on top of in...
My right hon. Friend seems to be making an excellent case for ending the gold-plating of regulati...
I certainly do not want to venture on to the particular terrain where my hon. Friend tempts me, b...
The Bill is about cultural change compared with what we saw under the previous Government, when t...
I pay tribute to my hon. Friend for his part—which was signal and tremendously important—in advan...
My right hon. Friend said that the Bill’s provisions were being introduced on the advice of those...
I am grateful to my hon. Friend, the Chairman of the Select Committee on Culture, Media and Sport...
As my right hon. Friend says, the reason this problem arises is that criminal procedure rules are...
My right hon. Friend, who obviously has an immensely distinguished record of concern for civil li...
My right hon. Friend said that the clause would affect self-employed people. Will it also affect ...
That is a very interesting question, which will need to be discussed in Committee. I am sure that...
I notice that my right hon. Friend has scampered past clause 13, which touches on the issue of ri...
Yes, I can give my hon. Friend some comfort on that. Incidentally, it is rather interesting to he...
I am very grateful for what my right hon. Friend says about that because it can take up to 12 yea...
I very well know the phenomenon. In fact in the case I was talking about, I think it has taken ab...
Will that guidance also refer to the issue of green lanes which has come up among my constituents...
Well, to say that I have been lobbied about these matters is mild understatement. I think it woul...
Rarely have we debated a Bill that is so long and so broad and yet so ineffectual, given what it ...
I am grateful to the hon. Lady for giving way, and I assure her that I shall not seek to interven...
I find it hard to believe that the Minister has intervened to make a point for which he has so li...
The hon. Lady might wish to reconsider those remarks. When we checked with the House of Commons L...
The figures that I gave were accurate. Speaking of the regulations that we brought in, was the ho...
No; what I am against is Opposition spokesmen standing at the Dispatch Box pretending that they s...
The hon. Gentleman would be pleased if his Government had our record on growth and business start...
Perhaps the hon. Gentleman has something to say about knitting yarn.
My right hon. Friend the Minister for Government Policy made the point that there is a lot of reg...
I know that the Government face a real challenge in keeping their Members off the subject of Euro...
Perhaps the hon. Gentleman has something to say about that.
It appears that the hon. Lady is going to oppose every measure in this Bill. Is that the case?
There are some measures in this rag, tag hotch-potch of a Bill that are welcome and that we do no...
Does the hon. Lady not agree that the cumulative effect of the Government’s reforms of small busi...
We all know that small businesses need a cut in business rates, as we have proposed, and then a f...
The hon. Lady talks about preventing mythical attacks on working people. Does she concede that un...
I know that almost 1 million young people are unemployed and that 1.3 million people in part-time...
I am not sure how often the hon. Lady talks to business, but perhaps she saw the submission from ...
I have just quoted the FSB, which stands for the Federation of Small Businesses—I hope that the h...
Order. Mr Maynard, I do not need comments like that. We are listening to a debate. I know that it...
On a point of order, Madam Deputy Speaker. I made the comments; I would not like my colleague to ...
It is very gallant of the hon. Gentleman to offer that information. I will say to him as well tha...
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I hope that the new employees will succeed in making the M...
Does the hon. Lady welcome the shared parental leave that the Government have introduced as part ...
The Labour Government did more to support working families and working parents than any Governmen...
I am going to make progress, as many Members wish to speak.
Regulation is a concern for som...
I am sorry to put the hon. Lady out of her stride, but I have slightly lost her point; I will be ...
I thank the Minister for his intervention, which, I regret to say, illustrates that this Governme...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
I am just finishing.
Once again, this Government’s rhetoric extends far beyond their reach....
I rise to give my full support to the Bill, which represents another important clear-out of unnec...
We cut Labour’s jobs tax.
Absolutely.
The duty to pay employer’s national insurance contributions for people under 21...
I fully support my hon. Friend’s comments. Does he agree that the Minister for Government Policy,...
I agree with my hon. Friend completely. There has been great determination not only to reduce the...
As co-chair of the all-party group on mountaineering, what is the hon. Gentleman’s view of how cl...
The hon. Gentleman makes an interesting point, and I am sure that he and I will wish to debate it...
I will try to respond to that point before I hand over to the Minister. Surely the purpose of cla...
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for giving way because this is a beautiful illustration of the pr...
I thank the Minister for that reply. I am sure that the hon. Member—and friend—for Bassetlaw (Joh...
I think that my hon. Friend was on the trip to Brussels when we asked the Commission whether it h...
My hon. Friend makes an important point that further highlights something I said earlier: 72% of ...
My hon. Friend knows, as I do, that large businesses rather welcome a heavily regulated environme...
Absolutely. Providing for a more level playing field and enabling small and medium-sized enterpri...
Most of the hon. Gentleman’s speech seems to have been concentrated on the European Union. Is it ...
I am not sure that that contribution particularly advances the debate. I refer the hon. Lady to t...
I beg to move,
That this House declines to give a Second Reading to the Deregulation Bill b...
As the hon. Lady will be aware, employment tribunals made these recommendations only 19 times in ...
That is a clear example of where the status quo is not causing a problem. The Government are look...
The hon. Lady is making a serious speech; I hope I can correct just one misapprehension on her pa...
I thank the Minister for that clarification. That is not as I understood it, but I am pleased to ...
Apart from that one, rather spurious example, can the hon. Lady give the names of other business ...
I certainly can. I could talk about the Aldersgate Group as one or the Prince of Wales business t...
I ran a business for 22 years, and what small businesses knew under the last Labour Government wa...
I am not a spokesperson for the Labour party, but if the hon. Gentleman wants to ask that questio...
What does the hon. Lady think is the impact of deregulation on the interests of small business, a...
I certainly think that some deregulation can help small businesses, and I also think that small b...
I am very happy to be contributing to the debate. It is a particular pleasure for me because I se...
Does my hon. Friend agree that the Bill will drive future jobs and growth, will be welcomed by sm...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. As he has so succinctly put it, creating jobs and giving peop...
I know that my hon. Friend is keen to move on to specific aspects of the Bill, but may I ask her ...
My hon. Friend is right to ask that question. The Government have, of course, gone incredibly far...
My hon. Friend is making a passionate appeal for common sense and entrepreneurial values. As some...
I think that there is a correlation between what we have heard so far today and some of the Commi...
My hon. Friend is making a good point, which is that it is not just the businesses and small entr...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. This is about how we can transform the way public bodies, inc...
I would like to bring my hon. Friend back to the general principles and look at the bodies that r...
I thank my hon. Friend for his point on public bodies in particular. In the public bodies legisla...
Important points are being made in this debate. In Macclesfield we are very proud of our level of...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. Those of us who have worked in business are very aware that a...
In terms of job creation, does my hon. Friend agree that the Bill specifically addresses young pe...
My hon. Friend is right. There is rightly a focus on young people, but I come back to my point ab...
Having sat on the Joint Committee on the draft Deregulation Bill, the hon. Member for Witham (Pri...
It is a great pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Stoke-on-Trent North (Joan Walley), who chai...
Does my hon. Friend agree that European legislation comes into Whitehall and is embellished and m...
My hon. Friend makes a good point. He puts his finger on one of the big problems that we have had...
And so we move on from “Cash in the Attic”. I apologise to you, Mr Deputy Speaker, as although I ...
Just to correct the hon. Gentleman, nobody is removing a power; what is being removed is a duty. ...
I welcome that clarification, but it would be helpful and reassuring if there were guidance about...
I will certainly talk to my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Transport, and we will f...
I find that extremely helpful. I chair the RMT parliamentary group, and it would be really useful...
May I begin by welcoming the Bill and commending my hon. Friends the Members for Macclesfield (Da...
To give my hon. Friend some good news, we think that the figure is rather more like 2 million.
I thank my right hon. Friend for moving the goalposts in the right direction.
My hon. Friend is making a powerful case. Does he share my view that deregulatory steps such as t...
I certainly do. Having been a business owner under the previous Government, and representing busi...
More for the sake of accuracy than anything else, may I point out that the TUC is not affiliated ...
I thank the hon. Gentleman. I always try to be accurate in my abuse, as he well knows.
Busi...
I am glad to have the opportunity to say a few words in this debate. It is obviously right for Go...
In the light of the comments made by the hon. Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell), w...
I am grateful to the right hon. Gentleman for that helpful clarification.
Another question ...
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for making a characteristically thoughtful contribution. It s...
The Minister makes a constructive point and perhaps it can be pursued and tightened up in Committ...
Will my hon. Friend tempt the Minister to respond to him again to put the whole issue of sustaina...
My hon. Friend makes an important point, and if the Minister wishes to intervene to clarify the i...
Order. May I help a little? If we are to have interventions, could they be a little shorter, beca...
I am sorry, Mr Deputy Speaker. I accept this is a slightly odd way to conduct a debate, but it se...
I am grateful to the Minister for his comments, and I welcome his commitment to a balancing duty,...
I was on the Joint—or pre-legislative scrutiny—Committee, and it was quite evident that there has...
Just to clarify, we have almost completed discussing that matter, and by the time the Bill is con...
It is good news that, at least in Committee, people will have a much clearer understanding of the...
I rise to speak in support of the amendment that appears in my name and the names of the hon. Mem...
For this flagship Government Bill, one wonders where all the Tories have gone. They seem rather r...
I have not had time to flick through every clause in the Bill, but who was in power in 2004 when ...
As the hon. Gentleman said, he has not had time to read the Bill, which is why I itemised, for th...
The hon. Gentleman is making a passionate defence of the regulations under which he successfully ...
When even the Minister who is responding to the debate has not read the Bill it is a bit of a pro...
I am sorry; that is what fooled me.
I do not find it amusing that the Government introducing the Bill have no idea what goes on in wo...
I am listening carefully to the hon. Gentleman’s arguments. His scenario is that of several self-...
As I illustrated with the mining industry, if we move away from regulation, it will lead to civil...
Let me try and drag the hon. Gentleman back to the actual debate. With his vast business experien...
We are now dealing with the most extraordinary Conservative party. When the people being brought ...
I will take an intervention from the Minister who got the position on mountain guides wrong.
I am very grateful to the hon. Gentleman. I would scarcely have engaged in diminishing the brilli...
As the Minister knows, the definition of what is risk to other people is entirely subjective.
...I am sorry, but it will not be in any way subjective; it will be utterly objective in the sense t...
We will see which are included and which are not. When the Minister talked about mountain guides,...
The hon. Gentleman said that the Minister referred to the wrong regulator. May I then refer to th...
The HSE does not regulate training for mountain guides. As with any risk assessment, the responsi...
Given the hon. Gentleman’s aversion to releasing the self-employed who do not pose a risk to anyo...
I will not give a detailed exposition about climbing guides in France and Germany, save to say th...
As a Parliamentary Private Secretary, I am sorry to break the convention of the House by rising t...
The hon. Gentleman will therefore know that he has a legal duty, if he is taking people with him,...
Order. The hon. Gentleman has indicated that he is about to draw his remarks to a close after mor...
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Had they been required, I could have given a range of other exam...
We have had a series of bombshells during this debate. As became increasingly evident would be th...
I never said any such thing. What I was referring to was ludicrously overburdensome guidance that...
The phrase that the Minister has just used—straightforward, clear and to the point—is very import...
Of course I am happy to provide that clarification. When the shadow Minister sees the prescribed ...
That is helpful.
I thought the hon. Member for Macclesfield (David Rutley) made a great spe...
Has the hon. Gentleman not taken any notice at all of the debate about clause 1? There are plenty...
I will come to the precise benefits for business in a moment, but I want first to refer to the ho...
I will give way to the hon. Gentleman, who I know is very knowledgeable about business. Those sav...
Amen to the hon. Gentleman’s apparent call for the Government to take further action to deregulat...
When I speak to businesses, which I do every day, they tell me that the main factor affecting the...
A small and select group of specialist people have taken part in this debate, but it has been a v...
Will the right hon. and learned Gentleman give way?
The amendment is of course on the Order Paper, so I give way to the hon. Lady.
I have been advised that it will be helpful to the House to let the right hon. and learned Gentle...
I am very grateful to hear it because by its very nature a deregulatory Bill gives rise to many p...
No self-employed novelists have had health and safety inspections or a burden that they have had ...
I deliberately chose, as the hon. Gentleman did at the other extreme, the rather way-out example ...
The right hon. and learned Gentleman gives the example of a self-employed beekeeper. A beekeeper ...
I admire the eclecticism of the hon. Gentleman. I knew that I could not engage with him on mounta...