Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill
Tuesday, 21 May 2013
Bills
House of Lords
Wednesday, 12 June 2013
Parliamentary committees
House of Lords
Show all related items (6)
Moved by
Lord Curry of Kirkharle
20: Clause 4, page 5, line 33, at end insert—
...
My Lords, I am deeply concerned about the potentially divisive nature of this Bill. Mention was m...
Show all contributions (114)
My Lords, I rise to speak in favour of Amendment 22, which is in my name. Very detailed considera...
My Lords, I have been listening with great care to many of the arguments which the noble Lord, Lo...
I did not say that it was not the job of religions to go along with society. Religions are formul...
I do not wish to enter into what I think is something of a distraction. I agree with the noble Lo...
Again, I have not for a moment said that the rest live in a moral vacuum. I simply stated what re...
My Lords, I will address the amendments moved by the noble Lords, Lord Curry of Kirkharle and Lor...
It may be that no disrespect is intended, but disrespect has been taken and many people are extre...
I apologise if any disrespect has been taken; it was certainly not the intention. A general refer...
I am grateful for what has been said, but it does not really explain the concerns at all. If ther...
My Lords, this echoes precisely what I was saying at Second Reading. It is a very good example of...
My Lords, I appreciate the point that the noble Lord, Lord Singh, is making, but I ask him to ref...
My Lords, I would just add that if the state were to conduct such an exercise and purport to deci...
Having heard that, I will not move my amendment, with the proviso that what I have suggested shou...
Hear, hear!
Thank you, but I will not move my amendment.
My Lords, I reinforce that. The Bill itself, as I said in my comments and has been said numerous ...
Moved by
Lord Wallace of Tankerness
21: Clause 5, page 6, line 18, leave out from “pu...
Moved by
Lord Dear
23: After Clause 7, insert the following new Clause—
“School...
My Lords, I see that Amendments 23 and 24 are grouped together. I had discussions earlier with th...
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Dear, brought to the attention of the House certain remarks made b...
Teachers in any context need to teach the legal position. Is the noble Lord suggesting that they ...
I appreciate what the noble Lord has to say and he will be able to say it in his speech. I wish h...
I was shaking my head because I do not believe that it is difficult for a teacher to teach the fa...
A number of teachers will find it extremely difficult to have to explain the new regime. At Secon...
My Lords, I say in a spirit of courtesy that I rather resent the reference to this side of the Ch...
I wonder whether the noble Baroness could apply that reasoning to the letter that I quoted. I wil...
My Lords, my experience in my political career is that it is unwise to comment on individual case...
My Lords, we all recognise the strength of feeling that these issues command, and pleas for toler...
Would the noble Lord then distinguish that from the circumstances of a teacher who is an atheist ...
An atheist may have good reason for not teaching religious education, because by definition relig...
With the greatest possible respect, that is dancing on a pin. I am sorry to put it that way, beca...
My Lords, would the noble Lord, Lord Dear, please accept that he is referring to two separate iss...
My Lords, perhaps I may put in my 10 cents-worth on this. I entirely agree with the noble Lord, L...
I wonder if the noble and learned Baroness has seen the Secretary of State’s Second Reading speec...
I very much hope that that is true. It may be that this is not necessary in primary legislation. ...
My Lords, does the noble and learned Baroness accept that I have failed to convey the message of ...
I do not want to keep getting up and down. I entirely agree with the noble Baroness, but since sh...
My Lords, I have waited patiently and tried about five times to get in, because this part of the ...
My Lords, I shall be brief because I know that the Committee wants to make progress and there is ...
My Lords, there are a couple of things which have not been mentioned that we need to bear in mind...
My Lords, I believe that it was the noble Lord, Lord Dear, who said that this is something of kni...
In the spirit of tolerance that the noble Lord, Lord Waddington, asked for, will the noble Lord a...
I am very sorry to hear the noble Lord say that because I certainly do not want to offend him or ...
I remind the noble Lord that the example in Lancashire that I spoke of was in a Church of England...
I thank the noble Baroness for that intervention, which reminds me, if I needed reminding, of her...
My Lords, I hesitate to intervene because I have not spoken since Second Reading. However, I want...
My Lords, I have a question for the Minister arising from the speech of the noble and learned Bar...
The noble Lord has not, as far as I know, addressed his second amendment at all. I do not think t...
I will address both Amendment 23 and Amendment 24, as the noble Lord, Lord Dear, himself said—
I am so sorry. Perhaps I may directly address the Front Bench. We agreed that we would try to hur...
I apologise to the noble Lord if I was in any way unclear when we discussed this. I thought, from...
If it is the will of the Committee I will move on to Amendment 24. Yes, the Front Bench is noddin...
My Lords, third time lucky. Amendments 23 and 24 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Dear, addres...
My Lords, as I said to the noble Lord, Lord Dear, I am grateful to be able to respond to his Amen...
Did I understand my noble friend to say that parents are not now allowed to withdraw their childr...
I am happy to confirm to my noble friend that parents are indeed allowed to withdraw their childr...
I am very grateful to the Minister for the way in which she has summed up and the way in which sh...
Moved by
Lord Elton
24C: Clause 9, page 9, line 23, at end insert—
“(3A) Regula...
My Lords, I have gleaned a little popularity that way. I hope that I will now get a good receptio...
I assume that the noble Lord would like to move his amendment.
I thought commendation amounted to movement. However, I beg leave to move the amendment.
My Lords, Amendment 24C sets out a procedure for the conversion from civil partnership to marriag...
My Lords, I was very interested in the terms in which my noble friend asked me to do that. I wond...
My noble friend has neatly rolled up his previous amendment as well. I am aware of the Delegated ...
That said, and anxiously awaiting developments, which I hope will be ahead of Report stage so tha...
My Lords, I apologise. I gave notice that I had a point to raise, but it was drawn inevitably int...
Moved by
Lord Alli
26A: Clause 10, page 11, line 1, leave out subsection (3)
My Lords, the effect of Amendment 26A is to remove the schedule that converts same-sex marriages ...
My Lords, my amendments are grouped with that of the noble Lord, Lord Alli. The reason is of cour...
My Lords, I find this part of the Bill quite extraordinary. I have the greatest possible sympathy...
My Lords, Amendment 26A in the name of my noble friend Lord Alli would remove the special arrange...
My Lords, I welcome the opportunity to clarify how the Bill, which makes provision for marriage o...
But it does not have a legal status in Northern Ireland and Scotland because it is a marriage in ...
My Lords, the position is that, as things stand at the moment, there is no provision in either Sc...
My Lords, I always understood that the first purpose of an order was to be a blanket order to cov...
My Lords, the Scottish Parliament has agreed a legislative consent Motion to the provisions in th...
My Lords, does it not require a statutory provision in Scotland to make this work? Therefore, it ...
As ever, my noble and learned friend expresses it far more concisely than I do.
My Lords, I thank the Minister for that reply but, as he probably recognises, I am not happy with...
Moved by
Lord Trefgarne
27: After Clause 10, insert the following new Clause—
“...
This is in essence a probing amendment. However, like all good probing amendments, it has the mer...
My Lords, I recommend that the noble Lord, Lord Trefgarne, should google marriages at sea. It say...
My Lords, my noble friend’s amendment would enable marriages of same-sex couples to be conducted ...
My Lords, I have to be honest and say that I am more mystified than disappointed. Listening to th...
Moved by
Lord Mackay of Clashfern
33: Clause 11, page 11, line 4, at beginning insert...
This is an extremely simple point, but possibly of some importance. Clause 11 (1) says:
“In...
My Lords, I am grateful to my noble and learned friend and, as is clear from today’s list, this a...
My Lords, I am very grateful and am happy to withdraw the amendment on that assurance that Parlia...
Tabled by
Lord Stevenson of Balmacara
33A: Clause 11, page 11, leave out line 5 and i...
My Lords, I rise to move Amendment 33A in the name of my noble friend Lord Stevenson of Balmacara...
My Lords, this amendment seeks to ensure that the Bill would allow individuals who identify thems...
My Lords, I thank the Minister for her understanding response. It is the first time, I think, tha...
Moved by
Baroness Northover
38: Schedule 3, page 25, line 23, leave out “Paragraphs 1...
My Lords, in moving government Amendment 38 I will speak to the other government amendments in th...
Moved by
The Lord Bishop of Guildford
39: Schedule 4, page 26, line 32, leave out par...
My Lords, it is agreed on all sides that parents make the most fundamental contribution to the fl...
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Northbourne, has asked me to speak on his behalf to Amendment 39A,...
My Lords, I want to thank the right reverend Prelate for the speech that he just gave. I thought ...
My Lords, my noble friend Lady Royall and I came to the same conclusion as the right reverend Pre...
My Lords, I understand why noble Lords would want to seek clarification on this aspect of the Bil...
Moved by
Baroness Butler-Sloss
40: Schedule 4, page 27, line 4, leave out paragraph 3...
My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 40 and 41. This is a sensitive issue and we are speaking, of...
Again, I support a probing amendment. I am concerned that marriages between people of the same se...
I thank the noble and learned Baroness for bringing forward this amendment. I have listened to wh...
My Lords, I will merely say that my noble friend Lord Alli has put his finger on the point. This ...
My Lords, I was wondering earlier how BBC Parliament would cope if this group of amendments came ...
They could turn the lights down.
At least we are not going to be subject to an inquiry by Ofcom.
The effect of the amendment...
I have perhaps found this topic rather easier to talk about, having been a divorce judge and inde...
I hope the noble and learned Baroness will forgive me for intervening very briefly. I absolutely ...
I hear what the Minister says and of course I accept that she is saying on behalf of the Governme...
Moved by
Baroness Stowell of Beeston
42: Schedule 4, page 28, line 13, leave out “as ...