My Lords, I am really rather appalled by what the Government are proposing and largely reassured by what my noble friend is proposing. I want merely to ask my noble friends on the Front Bench and those in my party and the Liberal Democrat party in government to consider for a moment what a very large number of people who live in houses with small narrow gardens bang up against people next door, either on one side or both.
A neighbour has enormous power over the comfort and convenience, and indeed the property value, of the people on either side. Throwing up something that looks into your garden, blocks the light from your flower-beds or makes you feel in some way claustrophobic can actually blight people’s lives. It is essential for the Government to realise that a great number of people— I declare an interest; I am one of them—live in circumstances where we are all in the hands of our neighbours as regards our comfort and the “quiet enjoyment” of our property, as the common law says.
As the noble Earl, Lord Lytton, very eloquently put it, when the air, light and privacy of one’s life are at the disposal of one’s neighbour, there must be some ready course of arbitration or judgment that is in one’s power to initiate, is not cripplingly expensive and does not take for ever. It seems that my noble friend is offering that and the Government are not. Therefore, there is no question who I would support.