Holocaust Memorial Bill
Wednesday, 17 April 2024
Parliamentary committees
House of Commons
Monday, 20 May 2024
Command papers
House of Lords
House of Commons
Wednesday, 22 May 2024
Parliamentary proceedings
House of Commons
I remind Members that, in Committee, Members should address the Chair not as Madam Deputy Speaker...
I beg to move amendment 6, in clause 1, page 1, line 9, at end insert—
“(d) educational pur...
Show all contributions (108)
With this it will be convenient to consider:
Amendment 1, page 1, line 9, at end insert—
When someone asked me if there was going to be a general election soon, I thought they must have ...
May I just clarify something that my hon. Friend has just said? He stated that £40 million has al...
I think that is the right figure, but the Minister will know. I am just a Back Bencher, and have ...
I thank the Father of the House for giving way. He is making an important point about how Victori...
My hon. Friend is right. She has the advantage of having led Westminster City Council and will no...
We could have had a fantastic, beautiful, moving memorial—roughly the same size as the Buxton mem...
My right hon. Friend is right, and most people will agree with him, even if their job is to stand...
I call Wera Hobhouse.
Excuse me, Madam Chair, but I wish to speak only on Third Reading.
Certainly—I was calling the hon. Lady because she is the only Member on the Opposition Back Bench...
Thank you, Dame Eleanor. I wish to speak to amendment 1 and new clause 1 and take the opportunity...
Does my hon. Friend agree that there is a serious issue regarding the security of Victoria Tower ...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. Security issues should be one of our key considerations as a ...
I will address the security issue in my speech, but I think it is all the wrong way round to make...
Security is one of the many considerations with regard to the site, and I think it is a valid one...
I apologise if I am taking words out of my hon. Friend’s speech before he gets to them, but was i...
My hon. Friend is exactly right—he certainly did so at that time.
I have tabled two amendme...
First, I thank the Holocaust Memorial Bill Select Committee for its very hard work. That Committe...
I thank my hon. Friend for giving way and for all her hard work campaigning on this issue. I was ...
My hon. Friend makes an excellent point. Having read the Select Committee’s report, it is clear t...
Has my hon. Friend had the opportunity to be in Victoria Tower Gardens on a Saturday or Sunday mo...
I have seen that. It goes back to the point that for many of us in this Chamber this is a workpla...
I thank the hon. Lady her for her amendment, which I am happy to support. Members of the Buxton f...
I did not realise the family connection with the hon. Gentleman’s constituency. The Buxton memori...
My hon. Friend is making a powerful point, characteristically both passionate and knowledgeable, ...
I thank the Minister for that clarification. I absolutely welcome that. That is a very powerful m...
My hon. Friend is being generous with her time. It is not—
I am not entirely sure what has amused my hon. Friend the Member for South Norfolk (Mr Bacon), bu...
I thank the Minister once again for that very clear steer and clarification.
It may be too late for a manuscript amendment to the Bill to be accepted by Dame Eleanor—or Madam...
I thank my hon. Friend, the Father of the House, for his intervention. He makes a very clear poin...
On this whole question of precedent, as anybody who has served any period of time as a local gove...
I thank my hon. Friend for his intervention. He may recall that the planning authority chose to n...
Does my hon. Friend agree that that that cost is just one example of a system that does not work ...
I completely agree. Many of my constituents feel that this is being steamrollered and imposed on ...
It is a pleasure to follow right hon. and hon. Members, who have made very important and serious ...
Order. I appreciate that the hon. Lady is dealing with a highly emotive subject, and I think that...
Thank you, Madam Chairman. I appreciate and value your guidance and I will absolutely abide by it...
I rise to support the Bill in its entirety and against the amendments, which I think will only de...
The point my hon. Friend is making now was not one put forward by the commission, and it was not ...
I thank the Father of the House for that intervention. It is clear that the site was chosen by th...
From visiting really serious Holocaust museums, as I have done in Washington and Berlin, I know t...
I thank my right hon. Friend for that contribution. I am one of those who visited the original Ya...
I do not want to be nit-picking, but the southern part of the park is a children’s playground. Al...
We can debate whether the figure is 7.5% or 10%, but the key point is that more than 90% of the p...
It is a privilege to follow my hon. Friend the Member for Harrow East (Bob Blackman). Given the n...
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for giving way and glad to be hearing what he is saying, both giv...
They are indeed—it is a brilliant presentation. I am also very proud that every Holocaust Memoria...
East, of course—as someone from East Yorkshire, I say east is always best. My hon. Friend the Mem...
As Members know, everything must conclude by six minutes past 7, and I want to give at least eigh...
It is a great pleasure to follow my hon. Friend the Member for Brigg and Goole (Andrew Percy). If...
Forgive me.
The Jewish people in this country are a very small minority. There are many con...
I rise to speak in support of this Bill and against the amendments, however nobly argued and well...
I am afraid I will not give way, because I have already extended the patience of the Chairman.
I know that everybody is glued to their mobile phones about the announcement of the general elect...
Order. As I said, the conclusion of the debate is at six minutes past seven. There is clearly a b...
It is a pleasure to speak in this debate on behalf of the SNP. It is perhaps slightly unexpected ...
I call the shadow Minister.
Before I begin my brief remarks about the amendments, let me restate the Opposition’s support for...
There are two sides to this issue, one of which people will accept that the hon. Gentleman is spe...
I thank the Father of the House for his intervention. I certainly agree that that is one of many ...
Today in this Chamber, we have been united on the welcome return of my hon. Friend the Member for...
I doubt the Minister intends to be the first to accuse me of waving a white flag on anything. I p...
Let me say to my hon. Friend that there is no reason for use of the park to be disrupted. I am af...
Where we are sitting is an armed fortress—we cannot go anywhere without seeing policemen with sub...
My right hon. Friend raises a valid point. That is absolutely at the kernel of the plans on which...
On that point, will the Minister give way?
Will my hon. Friend allow to make this important point, knowing the seriousness with which he tak...
I do not dispute what the Minister has just said, but previously he quoted the planning inspector...
The planning inspector did the work that statute places upon them, to allow them to make a clear ...
Does the Minister not share my concerns about costs? It was £50 million in 2015. It is now estima...
My hon. Friend is right, and I will thank him properly on Third Reading, but may I just put on re...
My hon. Friend will clearly be aware that when the original proposals were put forward back in 20...
In broad terms, my hon. Friend is absolutely right in the way that he sets out how these things w...
The Minister makes an important point about how important it is to be able to have a moment of re...
Let me say this to my hon. Friend: before coming to this place, I heard in my professional life—I...
Will the Minister give way?
Let me finish this point, and then of course I will. My hon. Friend the Member for Worthing West ...
We will have no heckling from the SNP, thank you very much. It is where the throne sits. It is wh...
I am going to give way to a Tory.
On a point of order, Sir Roger. There are only two minutes left, and I had hoped to wind up the d...
I just wanted to point out that I was listening to my hon. Friend the Member for Worthing West (S...
I would have thanked my right hon. Friend for that intervention, but now I do not think that I wi...
If the figure spent already is £18 million and not £40 million, I accept that from the Minister, ...
I beg to move, That the Bill be now read the Third time.
Mr Deputy Speaker, may I begin by ...
I would like to make a speech.
In that case, I will not let the hon. Lady intervene. [Interruption.] Who was that? My hon. Frien...
I start by thanking the Clerks, the House staff and Library specialists for facilitating our deba...
I know that the hon. Member for Bath (Wera Hobhouse) will need to get in, so I will try not to sa...
I am extremely grateful for the opportunity to contribute to the debate, and I am grateful to the...
I listened very carefully to the speech by my right hon. and learned Friend the Member for Northa...
Does my hon. Friend accept that there are some of us who feel absolutely as passionately as he an...
Yes. The one thing I know from my 14 years and counting in this House is that their lordships loo...
I am glad to be able to contribute today on behalf of my party on this important Bill, albeit tha...
In the short time available, we should remember that the Holocaust represents the darkest hour in...
I congratulate the Minister, my hon. Friend the Member for North Dorset (Simon Hoare), on his tou...
Order. I am sorry to have to interrupt the right hon. Gentleman—there will be an opportunity to r...