Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill
Tuesday, 21 May 2013
Bills
House of Lords
Moved by
Lord Martin of Springburn
6: Clause 1, page 2, line 3, at end insert—
...
My Lords, I note that the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, is not here but I understand that the amendmen...
Show all contributions (71)
By adding a new layer to the process the amendment in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Morrow, ha...
My Lords, I appreciate that this is a probing amendment, but it has thrown up some interesting qu...
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Martin of Springburn, for giving us an opportunit...
I thank the noble and learned Lord. That clarifies the matter. So once again the papers have got ...
The position is as I understand the noble Lord to have described it: to my knowledge and that of ...
My Lords, I withdraw the amendment.
Moved by
Lord Dear
10: Clause 2, page 2, line 13, at end insert “or
( ) to expr...
My Lords, I rise briefly to deal with Amendments 10, 12 and 14. I said when I spoke to Amendments...
My Lords, these amendments are very similar to those we debated before the dinner break and, in a...
The amendments of the noble Lord, Lord Dear, provide an opportunity for me again to make clear wh...
Does the Minister think that the law is so adequate that these words are irrelevant or does she t...
I think it is both. They are not necessary and by being specific in this way, as I tried to expla...
My Lords, I am partly confused and certainly not in agreement with what I think I heard the Minis...
I am sorry to interrupt the noble Lord but I strongly object to what he has just said. There is n...
Of course, I defer to the noble Lord’s view on this but nevertheless we have heard of a number of...
Moved by
Baroness Cumberlege
11: Clause 2, page 3, leave out lines 21 and 22
My Lords, I will also speak to Amendment 16. The Bill as drafted does not allow registrars to ref...
The noble Baroness keeps referring to the case of Miss Ladele but has failed to inform the House ...
My Lords, my point was that it never needed to have come to court.
Our new clause would pro...
Will the noble Baroness inform the House whether a proposed new clause would open the door to reg...
My Lords, this debate is about same-sex marriages. That is what I am addressing. Surely we should...
It is a legitimate question. If the amendment were agreed, would the noble Baroness be opening th...
My Lords, this Bill is not about mixed-race marriages but about same-sex marriages. That is what ...
Does the noble Baroness know of any religious faith that would object to a mixed-race marriage?
No, my Lords, I do not know of any. I have just had little more to say before I finish. Our propo...
I have a question for the noble Baroness. If I understand her proposed new clause correctly, at t...
The noble Lord, Lord Alli, got it absolutely right. I will draw my remarks to a conclusion.
I apologise for intervening at this late stage of my noble friend’s speech, but I would like to b...
No, my Lords, I am not going into divorce. I am trying to keep my proposed amendment quite narrow...
My Lords, if this amendment is agreed to I cannot call Amendment 11A by reason of pre-emption.
My Lords, I support Amendment 16 of the noble Baroness, Lady Cumberlege, and I do so very much as...
My Lords, I also support the amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cumberlege. As sh...
My Lords, I have some hesitation in following the three very able speakers, with all of whom I ha...
My Lords, I hope that the Government will listen to the points that have been made and recognise ...
My Lords, I understand that it might seem unfair to the right reverend Prelate, or to the noble B...
I do not think that the initiative for the quadruple lock came first from the Churches. Rather, i...
I will repeat my offer. I am really happy to work with the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of H...
My Lords, I, too, confess to having some sympathy with the amendment, particularly as diluted by ...
Am I correct in saying that it is not a question of a judge declining to sit on a particular case...
I do not believe that to be so.
I am not so sure about that. Those who arranged the judicial calendar did have some regard to que...
My Lords, I listened to this debate with great care. It is one of the most important we have had....
Surely there is not likely to be any situation in which a couple go to a registrar who is seated ...
If I may respond, that situation is really an exercise of emotion rather than fact. The likelihoo...
But you are left with the possibility. What happens in a rural area where there are not that many...
With the greatest respect, we are trying to get to the facts in all these debates. If I may say s...
But which is none the less possible.
I live in a rural area and I looked into this. In rural areas particularly, registrars work in te...
None the less, I return to the point: the noble Baroness wishes to put in legislation the potenti...
My Lords, can the noble Baroness explain what in this amendment makes her think that the scenario...
Because the potential exists for that to happen. To go back to some recent examples, what if, pri...
My Lords, it is clear from all these debates and amendments that the feelings on either side are ...
My Lords, I am pleased to support Amendment 16, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cumberleg...
My Lords, I shall be brief because I am sure that we want to hear from the Front Benches fairly s...
I am sorry to interrupt the noble Baroness and take up more time but I do not think that any of u...
I completely understand that but the examples given are relatively few. One of them is abortion a...
My Lords, I have listened to this debate with some concern because we have heard references to co...
My Lords, it is trespassing very close on bedtime too, so I will not take much of your Lordships’...
That is not true.
Heads are being shaken all around. I would like to hear.
I apologise for intervening. It is quite possible not be married by the registrar who you see in ...
The registrar they meet will be able to distinguish their gender and he will put that into the ma...
That is what the amendment would provide, which is what we are talking about. Let us not spend to...
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Elton, is of course right. It is time we moved on and went home.
My Lords, I start by thanking my noble friend Lady Cumberlege for introducing this amendment, whi...
My Lords, the protection extends to conducting the marriage, not preparing for it.
My Lords, following that logic, surely a conscientious objection must be as much to facilitating ...
My Lords, I would like to start by thanking all noble Lords who have taken part in this debate. I...