Early Parliamentary General Election Bill
Before I invite the Prime Minister to move the Second Reading, I must announce my decision on cer...
I beg to move, That the Bill be now read a Second time.
It is now a week since Parliament v...
Show all contributions (302)
I give way to the hon. Lady.
I thank the Prime Minister for giving eventually giving way. [Interruption.] We can all go, “Ooh”...
I am astonished to hear that the hon. Lady thinks that she voted for the programme motion last we...
Will the Prime Minister confirm that the only indicative vote that passed through this Parliament...
My hon. Friend is entirely right and he speaks for his constituency; they want to deliver Brexit,...
That is why I hope that so many of our colleagues will support this Bill today, including the Fat...
My right hon. Friend was one of those who delayed Brexit in March by voting against departure the...
I am afraid that my right hon. and learned Friend is in error; I voted for the withdrawal Bill. I...
indicated assent.
I take his nod as assent to that proposition, because that is the way—
Will the Prime Minister look at the amendment tabled in my name, which suggests that if we work s...
I am very grateful to the right hon. Gentleman, who I know wants to deliver Brexit. I am afraid t...
Labour backs a general election because we want this country to be rid of this reckless and destr...
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
No, I will not. They are a Government that created the vicious hostile environment that saw our o...
I shall be voting against an early election today and encourage as many of my colleagues as possi...
I hope my friend will join in the campaign to defeat this Government and to bring in a Government...
I am extremely grateful to the Leader of the Opposition for giving way. May I say to him that, in...
I am looking forward to campaigning all over Scotland to support Labour candidates to be elected ...
I thank my right hon. Friend for giving way. I look forward to campaigning with him in Scotland i...
I thank my friend for that intervention and compliment her on her work. I agree that a public hol...
My right hon. Friend will know—and I raised this yesterday—that I have tabled a cross-party amend...
I thank my friend for that intervention. I am coming on to that in a moment, but I absolutely do ...
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
No, I will not give way.
What this legislation does is sum up in a couple of words the unde...
I look forward to getting out on the campaign trail and smashing the Conservatives at the ballot ...
My friend is right. Commonwealth citizens have permanently had the right to vote in British elect...
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
No, I will not give way.
On that point—
I have already said I will not give way, but I will say it again—no!
Order. The right hon. Gentleman should resume his seat. He has been in the House since 2001 so he...
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
I want to make the point that we want any election to involve as man...
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
I have already said that I will not give way, so I say it again for the fourth time—no!
In ...
I very much applaud the Prime Minister for the stand that he has taken continuously over the past...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I will not give way for a very simple reason, which is that both hon. Gentlemen have consistently...
Has the hon. Gentleman completed his oration?
indicated assent.
He has. [Interruption.] There is a rather unseemly atmosphere in here. Mr Linden, you are a very ...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Stone (Sir William Cash). I have to say that I thi...
As my right hon. Friend spells out, it is going to be quite straightforward for the SNP to write ...
Absolutely, and that allows me to ask the question: where is the Prime Minister? He seems to have...
Can the right hon. Gentleman tell me whether any other European countries offer European citizens...
If the hon. Lady had been listening, I just explained that we do that in Scotland. The problem fo...
When I first arrived in this House as a new MP nearly two and a half years ago, I knew that deliv...
Does my hon. Friend agree that the best way in which our governing party can face the electorate ...
I absolutely agree, because the deal is in the interests of our country and has been negotiated w...
The hon. Lady makes the case that a second referendum will not solve the Brexit impasse. I would ...
The Prime Minister’s Brexit deal was pulled the moment the programme motion was rejected—sadly. I...
Does the hon. Lady recognise that for the majority of Members here who are concerned that we are ...
The EU has made it clear since day one that we cannot discuss the detail on the future partnershi...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. I listened closely to the comments made by the hon. Member for C...
The hon. Lady has amended the record. [Interruption.] No, no, no—I do not require any help from t...
Further to that point of order, Mr Speaker.
Oh, if you really feel it is necessary.
I apologise if one Liberal Democrat Member was here last night, but as I see it, the hon. Member ...
I am perfectly well aware of that. The hon. Member for Liverpool, Wavertree has corrected the rec...
The question that we are grappling with in this House and, indeed, in the wider country is not ju...
If there was a vote across the whole country—one person, one vote—on the Prime Minister’s deal, m...
The hon. Gentleman and I have both been campaigning for a people’s vote. I believe that the ideal...
The hon. Lady and I have both stood on a platform asking for a people’s vote. My constituency is ...
The hon. Lady and I agree on much. I do want 16-year-olds and 17-year-olds to be able to vote. Th...
Has the hon. Lady considered the Liberal Democrats’ contribution to the present predicament? Thei...
While the Liberal Democrats were in coalition, there was not a referendum on our membership of th...
The hon. Lady says that there was not a referendum under the coalition as a result of the Liberal...
We then voted to pass an Act of Parliament to say that that should happen at the point of signifi...
On the question of trust, has not the hon. Lady said that her party’s policy is to have a second ...
I really have to scotch this suggestion. I am not going to change my basic belief, and, to be hon...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
I have not finished answering the hon. Gentleman’s colleague.
If we had a people’s vote on ...
Will the hon. Lady give way on that point?
I have answered the hon. Gentleman’s point. I am going to make some progress and let other people...
I think we have had a filibustering of democracy for much of the last year. We have had endless g...
May I say to the hon. Gentleman that he is just wrong? On the morning of the vote on the first pr...
I have absolutely no doubt, given the bad faith that has been exhibited over Brexit and this elec...
No, it is worse than that. In the morning, the Labour Chief Whip asked through the usual channels...
Is the right hon. Gentleman saying that the Labour party did not oppose the programme motion, bec...
If I may, I would not mind making a bit of progress.
On the grounds of consensus, why do th...
I have given way twice. May I continue? [Interruption.] I give way.
We opposed the programme motion because a major constitutional Act would have been put in place t...
I am not sure I buy that. I am sorry, but I simply do not. Every time we try to bring forward—
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I would like to just answer and then move on, if I may.
Every time we bring something to th...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I am not giving way because I want to answer the point made by the right hon. Member for North Du...
I ask the hon. Gentleman a simple question. If the Government are so proud of the withdrawal agre...
I do not buy that for one second. We had three withdrawal deal votes this summer.
I do not want an extended debate on this, but there is another good reason why the hon. Gentleman...
Again, I do not buy that. The Government have been led very well, and I will explain why, althoug...
I want to give my hon. Friend a bit of a breather. I understand his frustration. Until the last i...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
No. I am making an intervention on my hon. Friend. Eventually there was a consensus on the withdr...
My hon. Friend is spot on. To answer the hon. Member for Newcastle-under-Lyme (Paul Farrelly), I ...
No, please let me continue. I have not yet learned to say no—I need to do so. Nyet!
In the ...
I have respect for the hon. Gentleman. However, the Labour party did not stand on a manifesto to ...
I thank the hon. Lady for her intervention. The question was not framed in pejorative terms: are ...
Order. I have great regard for the hon. Gentleman’s perspicacity, but not for his failure to adhe...
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. I think I have been slightly thrown by taking so many interventi...
Do you know where you are?
Roughly, yes. About 10 minutes ago, I was making the point that we needed a new Parliament, befor...
Please let me make some progress. I will let the right hon. Gentleman intervene a little later.
My hon. Friend has just said that we need a new Parliament as if somehow a totally different elec...
No. My right hon. Friend makes a good point. I do not think the people made a mistake and one has...
But my hon. Friend will also know that at the bottom of page 36 of the Conservative manifesto it ...
Again, my right hon. Friend makes a perceptive point. It is not from lack of trying. We have had ...
The Prime Minister voted against it.
He did, but then he voted for the last one. [Interruption.] Does the hon. Lady wish to intervene?...
No, carry on Bob.
Thank you so much.
The Conservative party is, of course, the Conservative and Unionist party and I believe in equali...
I thank my hon. Friend for her point. Regardless of whether one agrees with the principle, we alm...
I am sorry, but I do not buy the claim that we do not have time to deal with 16 and 17-year-olds ...
Lowering the age limit is a significant point of principle and one should not do it in a rush. In...
Is it not the case that the Labour party voted for Brexit—the one that was in our manifesto, rath...
I suspect the answer to that is that I am sure the hon. Gentleman will enjoy telling his electora...
The hon. Gentleman says that Labour Members are constantly voting against Brexit, but he should r...
I would say that we have arguably spent 25 years debating it, certainly in some parts of Britain....
It was the Prime Minister and members of the European Research Group who voted down the previous ...
I think the Prime Minister voted for two out of four, which is more than most Opposition Members....
The hon. Gentleman says he will vote for any Brexit that comes forward. It has been seven or eigh...
For me, a customs union is not a realistic Brexit and it is not the kind of Brexit that was voted...
Mr Speaker, I cannot work out whether you are eating popcorn as you watch this extraordinary spec...
Cashew nuts.
Does my hon. Friend not agree with me that this election provides a fantastic opportunity for eac...
I thank my right hon. Friend for what I think was a friendly intervention. I am certainly learnin...
May I say to the hon. Gentleman that it is normally known in the trade as in-flight refuelling?
I have just been refuelled, Mr Speaker.
We were talking about the need for a new Parliament...
Are you winding up?
I am trying to. Does the right hon. Gentleman wish to intervene, or shall I just get on with it?<...
No, I’m waiting for you to finish.
Fantastic. For all those reasons, I very much want an election if we cannot have Brexit. Given th...
I begin with the revolutionary thought that if something was a bad idea yesterday, it might just ...
Does the right hon. Gentleman agree that the only way to completely remove no deal from the table...
Those are not the only ways. There are three ways to avoid no deal: we can revoke, as the hon. La...
I would like to proceed.
Secondly, what is the right way to reach a resolution on an issue ...
Does my right hon. Friend agree that this is simply a dreadful deal, that the attack on workers’ ...
I do. There are many other points about this deal that we should properly explore, not least beca...
The right hon. Gentleman said that he could not vote for the agreement because it still allowed t...
I voted for a number of proposals that would have kept us close to the EU economically, including...
Anyone on the Government Benches who voted against the withdrawal agreement proposed by the last ...
The right hon. Gentleman makes a very wise point. When hon. Members such as the hon. Member for E...
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
I am going to wind up soon. In my view, the right way to have dealt with this issue is not to do ...
It is important that we have a general election. When the question about Brexit was asked in 2016...
My hon. Friend articulately expresses how the EU referendum result was not based on what parties ...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. It is important that we go back and look at how we got to whe...
I am sorry to interrupt the hon. Lady’s attack on the Liberal Democrats. I did not vote for the r...
I assume that the word “you” was directed not at you, Mr Speaker, but at me, so I do not expect y...
Does my hon. Friend not think it bizarre that some people are arguing for a people’s vote 2019 wh...
My right hon. Friend tempts me, and since there are no time limits, I may well wax lyrical on tha...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
May I finish this point first? Otherwise I could be speaking for hours, and I am sure the House w...
On political tribes, I shall give way.
Will the hon. Lady please explain to me why the Government have not got Brexit through when they ...
Perhaps the arithmetic in the hon. Gentleman’s particular tribe is not as good as it might be. Th...
Just about everyone in the Chamber said that they respected the result of the 2016 referendum and...
I can only hazard a guess that certain parties saw it as politically expedient to suggest or impl...
Will the hon. Lady give way, on that point?
On political footballs? The hon. Gentleman plays the game very well, so I shall hand over to him....
On the subject of football, if the hon. Lady would like to buy my new book on football, she is ve...
On a scintilla of that argument I completely agree with the hon. Gentleman. However, I am going t...
I will not give way now as I want to respond to the intervention of my right hon. Friend the Memb...
Will my hon. Friend give way?
I will give way in a moment; I am in great demand. First, however, I will respond to my right hon...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
I hope the intervention is on this particular point of asking the same question, because I do wis...
My area, Newcastle-under-Lyme, voted 60% to 40%, some say 62% to 38%, to leave. During the last e...
I am glad the hon. Gentleman asked me that because my answer to my constituents then, now and in ...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
No, I am not going to have a two-way debate with the hon. Gentleman on this particular matter.
No; I said no, and I say no twice. Mr Speaker made a ruling on this earlier on, so the answer is ...
I will take my hon. Friend’s intervention before I get to that point.
I thank my hon. Friend very much for allowing me to intervene on her fantastic speech. She is mak...
I absolutely accept my hon. Friend’s point. I accept that there are people in my constituency, as...
Will the hon. Lady give way on that point?
On the point about honouring contracts, I shall take the hon. Gentleman’s intervention.
Honouring contracts: an excellent input. I should like to draw the hon. Lady slightly back toward...
Yes, we are discussing a Bill about having a general election. My point is that we need a general...
Can I just answer the previous intervention before I take any more?
If it is somehow politi...
I apologise for interrupting my hon. Friend’s articulate flow once again. I could not help but he...
My hon. Friend knows the minutiae of the 600-page White Paper produced by the Scots Nats. I am su...
On the sclerotic nature of this Parliament and whether a general election will somehow change tha...
I do not blame you at all for unleashing a vial across anybody, Mr Speaker. I understand the hon....
Does my hon. Friend agree that this is also about ending uncertainty? Only with a general electio...
I agree, but we also need to get on and discuss all the other issues. For example—this is not the...
It is dangerous to continue this “people versus Parliament” narrative, saying that Parliament is ...
I have, and the worst impact is the absolute uncertainty surrounding investment in our jobs and b...
To return to the Second Reading of this Bill, my hon. Friend faces a challenge from the Liberal D...
Order. I say very gently to the hon. Gentleman that there is a difference between a brief interve...
You are absolutely right, Mr Speaker. My inquiry was reaching its climax. I finish by asking my h...
It is always a pleasure to oblige the hon. Gentleman because his naughtiness is mitigated by his ...
I take your instruction, Mr Speaker, and I will not be diverted.
A general election allows ...
I have enjoyed every second of my hon. Friend’s 29-minute speech, and I am grateful to get in jus...
The right hon. Gentleman tempts me, because the culture and heritage goes back to the Romans in S...
On that point—
On Brenda of Bristol, I shall give way.
Has the hon. Lady completed her oration?
indicated dissent.
No, she is taking an intervention from none other than the hon. Member for Caithness, Sutherland ...
Mr Speaker, I rise as the unrecognised Liberal Democrat in this place and I apologise to the Cham...
I am not sure how that related to Brenda of Bristol, but the point I wish to make, before I start...
Right honourable.
He has risen to right. hon—I am so sorry and I apologise. He wishes to speak. When we are going o...
I wonder why on earth we need a four-hour debate, because we have a very simple choice: we either...
Does the hon. Lady agree that people outside might think it a little disingenuous of some Members...
A lot of people who have seen how Parliament works over the past few months will have seen that w...
I am very grateful to the hon. Lady for allowing me to intervene. As she and I both serve on Nort...
I take it that the hon. Lady will be voting against the general election.
indicated assent.
I do think that that is a hugely important issue, which has unity across this House. If the Leade...
I thought that I heard the Leader of the House say that one reason for keeping the House going un...
I absolutely agree with the hon. Gentleman. I hope that those whose business it is can sort out w...
I am most grateful to the hon. Lady for giving way. Under the previous Labour Government when Gor...
I am sure that the right hon. Gentleman will be able to make a contribution in Committee, when we...
The question before us today is: do we want a general election? Do the public want a general elec...
What the hon. Lady is saying is not exactly true, is it? It took her party two years and eight mo...
The point I was trying to make is that the Government have tried every avenue to deliver Brexit, ...
The argument that the proper thing to have done was to extend the time available is undermined by...
My right hon. Friend is exactly right.
The Prime Minister was told that he could not reopen...
I have given way to the hon. Gentleman already.
This is a question of trust. The British pe...
Order. I just say very gently to the hon. Lady that a copy of prospective amendments has been mad...
Thank you, Mr Speaker, for that guidance. I did notice that many other speakers mentioned the ame...
Order. I am not sure whether that was done in an arch way. It was advertised, and it has attracte...
Absolutely, Mr Speaker
I would like to discuss the issue of European citizens, which has al...
I put forward a private Member’s Bill to try to extend the franchise. Does the hon. Lady not agre...
I am reminded of the fact that when people start to get personal towards the Prime Minister or ot...
Order. I ask the hon. Lady to resume her seat. Either entirely of her own initiative—which is per...
Thank you, Mr Speaker; I appreciate your guidance on this matter. I hope you will not mind my res...
My hon. Friend is making a powerful case. I think she is saying that the Bill should be left as i...
I thank my right hon. Friend for his intervention; he is right.
We need to deliver Brexit a...
I am most grateful to the hon. Lady. May I politely suggest that colleagues have care and concern...
I agree. I plan to say a number of things, but I want to follow up on some of the things that hav...
Does my hon. Friend agree with me that it is even worse than that because Parliament was excluded...
I entirely agree with my right hon. Friend. It is ridiculous.
I represent a leave seat, and...
I thank the hon. Lady for making a passionate and amusing speech. I believe that she is making th...
The honest answer—I have truck with honesty—is that I am not entirely sure, but does the hon. Lad...
What is the hon. Lady’s view of the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011 in such a situation, where hu...
I do not speak for the Labour Front Bench or those who make policy, but the Act seems to have cau...
I am grateful to have been called when I was not able to be present for the whole debate. I will ...
Order. May I just very gently say, because the right hon. Gentleman implied that he would be brie...
I have to say, Mr Speaker, that the minute you rose I realised the error I had made in speaking i...
I hope you do not mind if I take a small intervention, Mr Speaker.
It will be a small intervention, Mr Speaker. I do not wholly agree with my right hon. Friend, but...
I am very grateful; my hon. Friend has been a wonderful colleague to me over many years. This pla...
I appreciate the right hon. Gentleman’s very kind and gracious remarks, and I will not forget the...
I will not be supporting a general election because I do not think that a general election will r...
As I made clear earlier, there are issues relating to the franchise, conduct and security of any ...
I will not give way because of the time.
I know, but I am conscious of other colleagues.
I pay tribute to all the organisations, par...
My constituents and constituents across Scotland will have their say in a general election on the...
I do not think that I will take my three minutes, Mr Speaker.
I do not fear an election, be...
A Government under siege from its own side, ignoring the advice of its more thoughtful friends an...
I am in favour of a general election: a general election on 7 May, when the sun is shining, when ...
This Government are in complete disarray. After yesterday’s vote, we now have a Prime Minister wh...
Will the hon. Lady give way?
I will not give way; time is very limited.
The purpose of a general election is to let the ...
I should like to begin by paying tribute to all right hon. and hon. Members who have contributed ...
I presume that as part of the Prime Minister’s general election campaign, he will make a grand to...
I thank the hon. Lady for her contribution. I do not know exactly where the Prime Minister will g...
I wonder whether the Minister can tell me how we will stop the paralysis if what is returned to t...
I heard the hon. Lady make that point repeatedly throughout the debate. The very simple answer is...
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
I think that I have dealt with the hon. Lady’s point.
Thanks to the Prime Minister’s effort...
Now that the European Union (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill has had its Second Reading, we should be ...
The problem with the argument advanced by the hon. Gentleman is that when we had the opportunity ...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. Many excellent speeches species were curtailed at three minutes ...
The Minister has two and a half minutes in which to develop his peroration, but the hon. Gentlema...
Thank you for that opportunity, Mr Speaker, but I think I will be able to do so in slightly short...
Under the Order of the House of today, we shall now—for which I may have to substitute “shortly”—...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker.
I am deeply grateful to the hon. Lady, who may be indulged at slightly greater length than would ...
This has been a fractious, challenging, controversial and difficult debate at times. Do you agree...
I agree. On the matter of exemplary behaviour, we can all learn from the hon. Lady. I know she di...