House of Commons Disqualification (Amendment) Bill

As usual, my right hon. Friend—he should be right honourable, but he is in fact my hon. Friend—is right. We have just seen an example of that. Allegedly, Labour Members had a free vote in the Division a few minutes ago, and outside in the corridor Members were asking which way to vote. They had no idea what they were voting on. Luckily, there were some Labour Whips there, helpfully indicating which way they should go on the free vote. We have had a problem in Parliament for more than 30 years. Members of Parliament are voting, not according to what a Bill is about, but according to what the Whips say. May I explain how most Bills go through the House of Commons nowadays? A Bill"““gets sent to the House of Commons where it's debated without diligence—because automatic guillotines cut time short. It's passed without proper scrutiny—because standing committees for Public Bills are stuffed with puppets of the Government. And it's voted through without much of a whisper—because MPs have been whipped to follow the party line.""We've got to give Parliament its teeth back so that people can have pride in it again—so they can look at it and say 'yes: those MPs we elect—they're holding the government to account on my behalf.'””" [Hon. Members: ““Hear, hear.””] No wonder there were cheers for that, because they are not my words, they are the words of my right hon. Friend the Member for Witney (Mr Cameron), the Prime Minister. By stopping Members of Parliament becoming Whips and stopping Whips telling Members of Parliament how to vote, we would help to address many of the Prime Minister's concerns; and as with so many other things, the Prime Minister is absolutely right: we need to bring power back to Members of Parliament and away from the Executive. The Bill would enact the Prime Minister's wishes. I have not had the opportunity to discuss the Bill with the Prime Minister, but I am sure that if he is available and my Bill goes to a Division, he will be in the Aye Lobby. One may even say that his words were uttered in the same spirit as those of Edmund Burke, that great Conservative thinker, who once said about the perfect MP that,"““his unbiased opinion, his mature judgment, his enlightened conscience, he ought not to sacrifice…to any set of men living.””" That is what we Members of Parliament should do, and it is what Parliament itself was set up for us to do. We should act on behalf of our constituents, and use our unbiased opinion and mature judgment to scrutinise every piece of legislation that comes our way so that we hold the Government to account, regardless of party politics. Burke could surely not have foreseen how hard it is today for a Member of Parliament to live up to his ideal. Sadly, all too many of us succumb to pressure from a particular set of men living: our flatterers, cajolers and bullies who make up our party Whips.