Health Bill [HL]

I think I would like to thank everyone who took part in the debate. I thank the Minister for her answer, but she was wrong. I was not concerned about the burden of regulation on shopkeepers; people will know from Second Reading that I have not found those arguments particularly compelling. My concern was about something different altogether: smuggling. It is entirely possible to go into shops in this country and buy cigarettes that are not on display and are not on any price lists. They come from abroad and there is a good reason why they are not on display: they are part of an illegal activity. My colleagues and I remain concerned that the more you move towards prohibition, the more you can open up opportunities for markets that are illegal. It was helpful that the Minister explained that the intention is that prices will be visible but will not be able to be used as an advertising and promotional tool. That clarity is very welcome, and on that basis I beg leave to withdraw the amendment. Amendment withdrawn. Debate on whether Clause 19 should stand part of the Bill.