UK Parliament / Open data

Alcohol Labelling Bill [HL]

Once again, the noble Baroness has put the case extremely well and I cannot really add to it. The key word is ““proportionate””. For the reasons that she mentioned and the comparison that she has drawn, this suggestion would be disproportionate. There is also a practical aspect. As I said at Third Reading of the Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill, our prisons are full to bursting. Unfortunately, the Government are creating more offences for which people can be sent to prison, but this is crazy for practical reasons let alone moral ones. I would have thought that a fine—possibly an unlimited fine—and not imprisonment is the right penalty for such an offence.
Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
701 c421 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Back to top